EDIC Fivestar Self-Contained Carpet Extractor Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are looking for edic fivestar self contained carpet extractor alternatives because your needs may differ from the original model. The EDIC Fivestar 401TR offers a compact 12-inch width and 40-pound weight for portable use. It features a self-leveling brush and handles upholstery and stairs. However, you might need a wider cleaning path or a different power source. The alternatives listed here were chosen because their specifications overlap with the original. This list includes 6 similar picks compared to help you find the right fit. Some options provide larger tanks for less frequent emptying. Others offer steam cleaning or battery operation. You can compare dimensions and weight to see which fits your workspace. This guide focuses on practical specs rather than marketing claims. You will see how each machine handles commercial or residential tasks. The selection covers various form factors, from walk-behind scrubbers to upright extractors. Each product is ranked by its suitability for specific cleaning scenarios. You can review the data to make an informed choice.
Our top pick: EDIC Fivestar Self-Contained Carpet Extractor.
How these units differ from EDIC
KARHDIR 22-Inch Walk-Behind Floor Scrubber
The KARHDIR RO850 is a walk-behind floor scrubber designed for hard surfaces, not carpets. It weighs 300 pounds and measures 50 inches long, making it far heavier and larger than the 40-pound EDIC Fivestar. While the EDIC offers a compact 12-inch width for portable use, the KARHDIR features a 22-inch cleaning deck for broad commercial hard floors. You should choose this unit only if your primary task is maintaining large hard-surface areas rather than extracting carpet stains. It lacks the self-leveling brush shoe and multi-surface versatility of the EDIC model.
SUNMAX 22-Inch Battery Commercial Floor Scrubber
The SUNMAX RT50 is an extra-large commercial scrubber weighing 330 pounds. It is significantly heavier and larger than the lightweight 40-pound EDIC Fivestar. With a 23-inch width and 45-inch length, it is built for expansive hard-floor maintenance rather than portable carpet extraction. This unit provides cordless operation and high-capacity scrubbing for facilities with sealed hard flooring. It does not feature the EDIC's self-adjusting brush shoe or lift-off bucket system. Pick this alternative if you need heavy-duty hard-surface cleaning and do not require carpet or upholstery extraction capabilities.
Dapper Supply 18.5-Inch Steam Carpet Extractor
The Dapper Supply DP-CCE1220 is a steam carpet extractor that weighs less than the heavier commercial units but lacks the weight specification in its data. It measures 44.5 inches long and 18.7 inches wide, offering a wider cleaning path than the 12-inch EDIC Fivestar. This unit provides heated cleaning for commercial carpets and includes off-aisle detail tools. Unlike the EDIC's self-contained bladder system, this model relies on steam generation. It is suitable for large carpeted spaces on 20-amp circuits. Choose this if you need steam sanitation and wider passes, accepting the trade-off of a different cleaning mechanism.
Dapper Supply 18-Inch Commercial Carpet Extractor
The Dapper Supply DP-CCE1206 weighs 190 pounds, making it much heavier than the 40-pound EDIC Fivestar. It features an 18-inch cleaning width, which is wider than the EDIC's 12-inch deck. This unit operates at a quiet 70 dB and has a 10-gallon capacity with a 50-foot cord. It is designed for daytime cleaning in busy office environments. The EDIC Fivestar is more portable and compact. Select this alternative if you prioritize wide coverage and low noise in commercial offices over the portability and self-leveling brush features of the EDIC model.
SANITMAX 18.5-Inch Walk-Behind Carpet Extractor
The SANITMAX SM350-2603 weighs 110 pounds, which is heavier than the 40-pound EDIC Fivestar but lighter than other commercial scrubbers. It measures 45.3 inches long and 18.5 inches wide, providing a wider cleaning path than the EDIC's 12-inch width. This unit delivers 160 PSI injection pressure and 21 kPa suction. It includes bundled detail tools for commercial facilities. The EDIC Fivestar offers a self-leveling brush and fold-down frame for restricted spaces. Choose this SANITMAX model if you need high-pressure extraction and strong suction for commercial floor plans with ground-floor access.
Powr-Flite 9-Gallon Self-Contained Carpet Extractor
The Powr-Flite PFX900S weighs 100 pounds, making it significantly heavier than the 40-pound EDIC Fivestar. It features an 18-inch coverage width, which is wider than the EDIC's 12-inch deck. This unit has a 9-gallon tank capacity and a 3-stage motor. It is designed for mid-sized commercial carpets requiring wide extraction passes. The EDIC Fivestar offers a self-adjusting brush and compact frame for portable use. Pick this Powr-Flite alternative if you need higher capacity and broader coverage for commercial carpet maintenance, and do not require the portability of the smaller EDIC unit.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
EDIC Fivestar Self-Contained Carpet Extractor
Best for: compact multi-surface carpet and upholstery extraction
- Compatible Surface
- Carpet, Upholstery, Stairs
- Color
- Blue
- Dimensions
- 23 × 12 × 24 inches
- Weight
- 40 pounds
View on Amazon: EDIC Fivestar Self-Contained Carpet Extractor Affiliate link
This self-contained extractor measures 12 inches wide, 23 inches long, and 24 inches high. It weighs 40 pounds and targets carpet, upholstery, and stairs. You get a self-adjusting brush, a fold-down handle, and an upright-mounted motor with an intercooler system. A lift-off bucket with bladder handles solution and recovery. This machine suits you if you need a compact extractor for narrow spaces and multiple surface types.
Pros
- Weighs 40 pounds with a folding handle for storage
- Self-adjusting, self-leveling brush and vacuum shoe match different carpet heights
- Lift-off bucket with bladder system eases filling and dumping
- Back panel accommodates accessory connections for upholstery and stairs
Cons
- Narrow 12-inch width slows down large open-area cleaning
- Solution and recovery capacity specifications are not published
Good fit if
- You clean stairs, upholstery, and carpets using add-on accessories
- You need a compact 40-pound unit that stores inside standard closets
- You want an adjustable handle tailored to different operator heights
Skip if
- You need a wide-path commercial machine for expansive open hallways
- You require hard floor scrubbing functions alongside extraction
Verdict: EDIC Fivestar Self-Contained Carpet Extractor delivers a compact 12-inch footprint and 40-pound build for portable cleaning. Its self-leveling brush mechanism and fold-down frame optimize operation in restricted spaces.
KARHDIR 22-Inch Walk-Behind Floor Scrubber
Best for: large commercial hard floor maintenance
- Form Factor
- Walk-Behind
- Cleaning Width
- 22"
- Tank Capacity
- 15.9 gal clean, 18.5 gal sewage
- Compatible Surface
- Hard Floors
- Dimensions
- 50 × 31 × 42 inches
- Weight
- 300 pounds
View on Amazon: KARHDIR 22-Inch Walk-Behind Floor Scrubber Affiliate link
The KARHDIR 22-Inch Walk-Behind Floor Scrubber is a commercial hard-floor machine designed for large areas. You get a 22-inch cleaning path paired with a 31.5-inch squeegee, clearing up to 32,000 square feet per hour. It carries a 15.9-gallon solution tank and an 18.5-gallon sewage tank, powered by a brushless motor. If you manage expansive sealed hard floors rather than carpets, this unit handles high-volume washing.
Pros
- 22-inch cleaning width and 31.5-inch squeegee cover up to 32,000 sq ft per hour
- High capacity 15.9-gallon solution and 18.5-gallon sewage tanks
- Brushless motor designed for low operating noise and long service life
- Includes an additional set of consumable replacement parts
Cons
- Configured only for hard floors with no carpet extraction support
- Heavy operational footprint weighing 300 pounds
- Bulky frame measuring 50 inches long by 31 inches wide
Good fit if
- You need to maintain large hard floors such as concrete, tile, epoxy, or sealed hardwood.
- You want large liquid capacities with 15.9-gallon clean and 18.5-gallon recovery tanks.
- You require a high cleaning rate of up to 32,000 square feet per hour.
Skip if
- You need a dedicated extractor to clean textile carpets.
- You cannot transport or store a 300-pound machine.
Verdict: KARHDIR 22-Inch Walk-Behind Floor Scrubber delivers high-capacity scrubbing across broad hard floors with its 22-inch deck and dual large tanks. It serves as an industrial hard-surface alternative rather than a dedicated carpet extractor.
SUNMAX 22-Inch Battery Commercial Floor Scrubber
Best for: large-scale commercial hard-floor maintenance
- Form Factor
- Walk-Behind
- Cleaning Width
- 22-Inch
- Tank Capacity
- 13.2-gal solution, 14.5-gal recovery
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Compatible Surface
- Hard floor, concrete, epoxy, tile, VCT
- Battery Runtime
- Up to 5 hours
View on Amazon: SUNMAX 22-Inch Battery Commercial Floor Scrubber Affiliate link
This walk-behind machine cleans hard floors using a 22-inch scrubbing path and a 31-inch squeegee. It runs on a 24V battery system that provides up to 5 hours of continuous operation per 8-hour charge. With a 13.2-gallon solution tank and a 14.5-gallon recovery tank, it handles large facility floors up to 30,000 square feet per hour. It suits you if you need dedicated commercial hard-floor maintenance rather than carpet extraction.
Pros
- Up to 5 hours of cordless runtime from a 24V battery system
- Large capacity with a 13.2-gallon solution tank and 14.5-gallon recovery tank
- 22-inch cleaning width and 31-inch squeegee clean up to 30,000 square feet per hour
- 200 RPM brush action with included brush, pad holder, and pads
Cons
- Designed only for sealed hard floors, not carpet extraction
- Weighs 330 pounds
- Requires approximately 8 hours to recharge
Good fit if
- You need to clean large commercial hard floors like concrete, tile, or epoxy.
- You want cordless operation that lasts through extended cleaning shifts.
- You prefer high-capacity tanks to reduce stops during large jobs.
Skip if
- You need an extractor specifically built for cleaning carpets.
- You cannot manage storage or transport for a 330-pound machine.
- You require a fast recharge cycle shorter than 8 hours.
Verdict: SUNMAX 22-Inch Battery Walk-Behind Floor Scrubber provides expansive coverage and cordless operation for facilities with sealed hard flooring. It serves as a heavy-duty alternative if your cleaning needs center entirely on hard surfaces rather than carpets.
Dapper Supply 18.5-Inch Steam Carpet Extractor
Best for: heated commercial cleaning on 20-amp circuits
- Form Factor
- Walk-Behind
- Cleaning Width
- 18.5"
- Tank Capacity
- 10.5 gal solution, 8 gal recovery
- Power Source
- 50 ft power cord
- Compatible Surface
- Carpet, upholstery, furniture, stairs
- Brush Speed
- 1,500 RPM
View on Amazon: Dapper Supply 18.5-Inch Steam Carpet Extractor Affiliate link
This walk-behind unit from Dapper Supply pairs an 18.5-inch cleaning path with an onboard 1,200-watt heater reaching 208.4°F. It holds 10.5 gallons of solution and 8 gallons of recovery water while running a 1,500 RPM brush and 120 PSI pump. A 10-foot hose and upholstery tools handle furniture and stairs. It suits you if you need heated extraction for commercial spaces equipped with standard 20-amp electrical circuits.
Pros
- Integrated 1,200W heater reaches up to 208.4°F in approximately one minute
- Large capacity with a 10.5-gallon solution tank and 8-gallon recovery tank
- 18.5-inch cleaning path with a 1,500 RPM nylon brush
- Includes a 10-foot hose, 3.5-inch upholstery tool, and 9-inch extension wand
- 50-foot power cord enables wide reach from outlets
Cons
- Requires a dedicated 20-amp circuit for its 2,500-watt total draw
- Generates a 75 dBA operating noise level
- Large footprint measuring 44.5 inches long by 18.7 inches wide
Good fit if
- You have access to 20-amp electrical outlets to handle the power draw
- You need heated cleaning reaching up to 208.4°F for embedded soil
- You want a walk-behind unit that switches to detail tools for stairs and furniture
Skip if
- You only have standard 15-amp power circuits available
- You require an extractor that operates below 75 dBA
Verdict: Dapper Supply 18.5" Steam Carpet Extractor delivers heated commercial cleaning with large tanks and off-aisle detail tools. It provides dependable coverage for large carpeted spaces when connected to a 20-amp circuit.
Dapper Supply 18-Inch Commercial Carpet Extractor
Best for: daytime carpet cleaning in busy office environments
- Cleaning Width
- 18 in
- Tank Capacity
- 10 gal solution, 8 gal recovery
- Compatible Surface
- Carpet
- Brush Speed
- 900 RPM
- Power Draw
- 1400 W
- Form Factor
- Commercial
View on Amazon: Dapper Supply 18-Inch Commercial Carpet Extractor Affiliate link
This commercial carpet extractor from Dapper Supply cleans carpets with an 18-inch working width and a 900 RPM brush motor. You get a 10-gallon solution tank alongside an 8-gallon recovery tank to limit water changes. It operates at 70 dB and includes a 50-foot power cord. This setup suits you if you need to clean carpeted office spaces or commercial floors during business hours without excessive disruption.
Pros
- 10-gallon solution tank and 8-gallon recovery tank
- 18-inch cleaning path covers large carpet areas
- 70 dB operating sound level for quiet daytime cleaning
- 50-foot power cord for extended reach
- 900 RPM brush motor backed by 1400W power draw
Cons
- Heavy build weighing 190 pounds
- Recovery tank is 2 gallons smaller than solution tank
- No built-in water heater listed
Good fit if
- You need a quiet 70 dB machine for daytime office cleaning.
- You want an 18-inch path and 10-gallon solution capacity for commercial carpet runs.
- You need long continuous reach using a 50-foot cord on 110V outlets.
Skip if
- You need a lightweight unit under 190 pounds to move up stairs without assistance.
- You require built-in heated water extraction.
Verdict: Dapper Supply 18-Inch Commercial Carpet Extractor delivers wide 18-inch passes and quiet 70 dB operation for commercial carpets. Its 10-gallon capacity and 50-foot cord make it well-suited for servicing large office floor plans.
SANITMAX 18.5-Inch Walk-Behind Carpet Extractor
Best for: commercial facilities needing high-pressure extraction and detail tools
- Form Factor
- Walk-Behind
- Cleaning Width
- 13.8-inch brush, 18.5-inch squeegee
- Tank Capacity
- 10.5-Gallon solution, 8-Gallon recovery
- Compatible Surface
- Carpet, stairs, upholstery
- Brush Speed
- 900 RPM
- Intended Use
- Commercial Use, Carpet
View on Amazon: SANITMAX 18.5-Inch Walk-Behind Carpet Extractor Affiliate link
The SANITMAX 160 PSI Walk-Behind Carpet Extractor is a commercial self-contained cleaning machine designed for routine carpet maintenance in schools, offices, and event spaces. It combines a 160 PSI pump, a 900 RPM powered roller brush across a 13.8-inch width, and an 18.5-inch vacuum shoe with 21 kPa suction. You also get a 10.5-gallon solution tank and an included detail hand tool for stairs and edges.
Pros
- High-pressure 160 PSI solution spray
- Separate 10.5-gallon solution and 8-gallon recovery tanks
- 900 RPM motorized brush with 21 kPa suction power
- Long 49-foot power cord with included hose and detail tool
Cons
- Heavy 110-pound operating machine weight
- 13.8-inch brush width is narrower than the 18.5-inch recovery path
Good fit if
- You need a commercial extractor rated up to 2,150 square feet per hour.
- You want an included hose and hand tool to clean stairs and upholstery.
- You prefer large-capacity tanks to minimize dumping and refilling cycles.
Skip if
- You need a lightweight unit that one person can transport upstairs easily.
- You require a brush agitation path wider than 13.8 inches.
Verdict: SANITMAX 160 PSI Walk-Behind Carpet Extractor delivers strong 21 kPa suction, 160 PSI injection pressure, and bundled detail tools for commercial floor plans. Its 110-pound frame makes it best suited for facilities with ground-floor access or elevators.
Powr-Flite 9-Gallon Self-Contained Carpet Extractor
Best for: mid-sized commercial carpets needing wide extraction passes
- Cleaning Width
- 18-in.
- Tank Capacity
- 9 gal solution, 6 gal recovery
- Compatible Surface
- Carpets, area rugs
- Brush Speed
- 1300 RPM
- Form Factor
- Commercial
- Intended Use
- Commercial Use, Carpet
View on Amazon: Powr-Flite 9-Gallon Self-Contained Carpet Extractor Affiliate link
This self-contained carpet extractor pairs a 9-gallon solution tank with a 6-gallon recovery tank. You get an 18-inch cleaning path powered by a 1300 RPM brush roll and a 3-stage vacuum motor. Independent switches let you control the pump, vacuum, and brush separately. Built with a polyethylene body weighing 100 pounds, it suits mid-sized commercial spaces like schools, offices, and hotels needing deep extraction across large carpeted areas.
Pros
- 18-inch cleaning path with 1300 RPM chevron brush
- 9-gallon solution tank and 6-gallon recovery tank
- 3-stage vacuum motor for water recovery
- Separate switches for vacuum, brush, and pump
Cons
- Weighs 100 pounds
- Upholstery tool is optional and not included
- Recovery tank holds 3 gallons less than the solution tank
Good fit if
- You need an 18-inch cleaning width to cover mid-sized commercial floors.
- You want separate switch control for the brush, pump, and vacuum systems.
- You clean carpets and area rugs that require high-RPM brush agitation.
Skip if
- You cannot transport or maneuver a 100-pound machine.
- You need equal solution and recovery tank volumes to avoid mid-job emptying.
Verdict: Powr-Flite 9-Gallon Self-Contained Carpet Extractor delivers broad 18-inch coverage and high-speed brush agitation for commercial carpet maintenance. Its 3-stage motor and separate component switches provide practical control for mid-sized facilities.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | EDIC Fivestar Self-Contained Carpet Extractor | KARHDIR 22-Inch Walk-Behind Floor Scrubber | SUNMAX 22-Inch Battery Commercial Floor Scrubber | Dapper Supply 18.5-Inch Steam Carpet Extractor | Dapper Supply 18-Inch Commercial Carpet Extractor | SANITMAX 18.5-Inch Walk-Behind Carpet Extractor | Powr-Flite 9-Gallon Self-Contained Carpet Extractor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Form Factor | not stated | Walk-Behind | Walk-Behind | Walk-Behind | not stated | Walk-Behind | not stated |
| Cleaning Width | not stated | 22" | 22-Inch | 18.5" | 18 in | 13.8-inch brush, 18.5-inch squeegee | 18-in. |
| Tank Capacity | not stated | 15.9 gal clean, 18.5 gal sewage | 13.2-gal solution, 14.5-gal recovery | 10.5 gal solution, 8 gal recovery | 10 gal solution, 8 gal recovery | 10.5-Gallon solution, 8-Gallon recovery | 9 gal solution, 6 gal recovery |
| Power Source | not stated | not stated | Cordless | 50 ft power cord | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Compatible Surface | Carpet, Upholstery, Stairs | Hard Floors | Hard floor, concrete, epoxy, tile, VCT | Carpet, upholstery, furniture, stairs | Carpet | Carpet, stairs, upholstery | Carpets, area rugs |
| Battery Runtime | not stated | not stated | Up to 5 hours | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Brush Speed | not stated | not stated | 200 RPM | 1,500 RPM | 900 RPM | 900 RPM | 1300 RPM |
| Power Draw | not stated | not stated | not stated | 2,500 Watts | 1400 W | not stated | not stated |
| Special Feature | not stated | not stated | not stated | Steam | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Intended Use | Carpet | not stated | Commercial Use | Commercial Use, Carpet | Commercial Use, Carpet | Commercial Use, Carpet | Commercial Use, Carpet |
| Color | Blue | Turquoise | Orange | Grey | Grey | Blue | Black |
| Recommended Location | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Offices | not stated | Offices |
| Runtime | not stated | not stated | 5 Hours | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | 23 × 12 × 24 inches | 50 × 31 × 42 inches | 51.2 × 31.5 × 38.2 inches | 44.5 × 18.7 × 34 inches | 34 × 18.7 × 34 inches | 45.3 × 18.5 × 36.2 inches | not stated |
| Weight | 40 pounds | 300 pounds | 330 pounds | not stated | 190 pounds | 110 pounds | 100 pounds |
| Model | 401TR | RO850 | RT50 | DP-CCE1220 | DP-CCE1206 | SM350-2603 | PFX900S |
| Size | not stated | not stated | Extra Large | not stated | 18" | 45.3x18.5x36.2 Inch | 9-gallons |
If you want automated daily maintenance alongside a deep extractor, compare these bagotte self emptying robot vacuum alternatives.
Frequently asked questions
Which alternative is best for tight spaces?
The EDIC Fivestar remains the top choice for compact areas. It measures 12 inches wide and weighs 40 pounds. Its fold-down frame allows for easy storage. Other options like the KARHDIR weigh 300 pounds and require wide aisles. The Dapper Supply 18-Inch model is also lighter at 190 pounds but still wider than the EDIC.
Are there walk-behind scrubbers for hard floors?
Yes, the KARHDIR and SUNMAX models serve this purpose. The KARHDIR features a 22-inch cleaning width and weighs 300 pounds. The SUNMAX is battery-powered and weighs 330 pounds. These units are designed for sealed hard surfaces. They are not suitable for carpet extraction or upholstery cleaning.
What is the lightest carpet extractor option?
The EDIC Fivestar is the lightest at 40 pounds. The Powr-Flite follows at 100 pounds. The SANITMAX weighs 110 pounds. The Dapper Supply 18-Inch model weighs 190 pounds. The heavier walk-behind scrubbers exceed 300 pounds. Choose the EDIC if portability is your primary requirement.
Which extractor is suitable for busy offices?
The Dapper Supply 18-Inch Commercial Carpet Extractor is ideal for offices. It operates at a quiet 70 dB. It features a 50-foot cord for large floor plans. The EDIC Fivestar is also compact but lacks the wide 18-inch pass. The Dapper Supply model balances noise levels with efficient coverage.
Do any models include steam cleaning?
The Dapper Supply 18.5-Inch Steam Carpet Extractor includes steam functionality. It requires a 20-amp circuit for operation. This model provides heated cleaning for commercial spaces. Other listed extractors rely on water injection and suction without steam generation. Verify your electrical capacity before selecting this specific unit.
Which unit offers the highest injection pressure?
The SANITMAX 18.5-Inch model provides 160 PSI of injection pressure. It also delivers 21 kPa of suction power. This high pressure aids in deep extraction for commercial facilities. The EDIC Fivestar and other compact units do not list specific PSI ratings. Choose the SANITMAX for heavy-duty pressure requirements.
Is there a battery-operated option for carpets?
The SUNMAX model is battery-operated but designed for hard floors. It is not a carpet extractor. All other listed carpet extractors are corded units. The EDIC Fivestar, Dapper Supply, and Powr-Flite models require electrical outlets. You must use a corded machine for carpet extraction from this list.
What is the maximum cleaning width available?
The KARHDIR and SUNMAX offer a 22-inch cleaning width. The Dapper Supply 18.5-Inch and Powr-Flite provide 18-inch coverage. The EDIC Fivestar has a 12-inch footprint. Wider decks cover more area per pass. Select a wider model for large, open commercial spaces rather than tight residential areas.